Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Viral Sheth's avatar

hi , so wanted to highlight one key point about WTI and Brent crudes, even though WTI is lighter than Brent, internationally WTI istill trades at a discount to Brent , mainly to the energy infrastructure and ease of trainspotting the brent crude variants. WTI is mostly landlocked in the US and far for most eastern customers ..

Priyans's avatar

Hi,

Mahindra's current EVs have cells from different vendors but not VW. Yes, there is a deal between VW and Mahindra, but we haven't seen their battery packs in cars yet.

Mahindra sources the cells from BYD and assembles the pack themselves, whereas Maruti imports the entire battery pack from BYD. Mahindra had no native ability to assemble battery packs, whereas TDSG has been assembling for more than a year.

I've made a list of the major Indian car OEM models and their cell suppliers here - https://www.expwithevs.in/i/173414503/lifetime-warranty

Another point to note - Maruti's top model with 61kWh battery is priced at 19.79L. Mahindra's BE6 with similar battery capacity of 59kWh starts at around 18-19L.

Mahindra's BE6 has better features than Maruti's. Feature appreciation might be subjective, but a base model BE6 can charge almost 2 times faster than the top model Maruti.

My point here is, Maruti is not being Maruti in producing cheap cars because it doesn't have the technology for EVs.

Maruti's management says that there's government support for EVs, but refuses to acknowledge that there's government PLI support even for manufacturing advanced ICE components too.

Another reinforcing point is - when critical minerals shortage happened, some Indian OEMs like Ather put in the RnD efforts to develop a Heavy Rare Earths Free motor, but Maruti decided that it is better to cut down their production. It didn't look for alternates or invest more in RnD.

All of this goes to show that Maruti - given the giant it is - doesn't like to move much, or rather go back to the drawing board and start something fresh.

The eVitara is a product based on 2020 technology, launched in 2025 for the world.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?