The distinction between onshore panda bonds and offshore dim-sum bonds is important when interpreting the issuance boom. A lower yuan yield can attract borrowers without proving that the currency is displacing the dollar in global reserves. For a borrower whose revenues are in another currency, the cost and availability of hedging also matter alongside the headline coupon. How much of the recent issuance reflects natural yuan funding needs versus borrowers swapping the proceeds into another currency?
So Andy Mukherjee, who we quoted at the start of the piece, takes the exact opposite position. He believes that the yields themselves fundamentally reflect perceptions of investor stability. Now, it's very likely that the dollar will stabilize again - it's the dollar, after all. But this might be a step above mere currency arbitrage (which is what happened in earlier episodes of yuan bond booms).
That distinction between currency use in long-term assets and everyday transactions is helpful; deeper bond markets can develop without immediately changing reserve behavior. What evidence would you watch to tell whether that transition is actually accelerating?
Good piece. The number that stayed with me is the gap itself. China ten year at about 1.6 percent, the US ten year at 5.34 percent in early October. When borrowing in yuan costs a third of borrowing in dollars, the boom needs no grand story about the dollar losing its crown. It is arithmetic. The part I keep thinking about is who pays for the cheap price. Chinese savers earn under 1 percent on a one year deposit while their savings fund the bonds, so the subsidy runs from households to borrowers. That is why I read this as a funding trade, not a reserve currency shift. The dollar is still about 57 percent of global reserves. The boom lasts exactly as long as the rate gap does, and after a hot CPI print that gap is the thing to watch.
Bring the ATF under GST or under uniform VAT percentage across states. Similar to GST cuts of last year, maybe more people flying will offset loss in revenue because of change in taxes...
While India may be cheapest amongst highest 7 flying markets, not sure whether this is PPP adjusted, flying is still expensive for even the average office going Indians, forget the rest..
Maybe more premium trains like VB sleeper across major cities will be people's alternatives to flying..
On the PPP front, you got the argument correctly. Adjusting for affordability, even though the prices looks the least amongst other nations, its still out of reach for many and there's no denying that.
As for alternatives to flying, we too wanted to pursue this angle in our story, but couldn't find convincing enough data points and evidence to include it. So we decided to skip it for now, but will for sure keep a track of it.
Two types of bonds from same underlying currency with the intent to spread the currency globally….interesting…but difficult to understand how can that help in improving the currency domination in global transaction and eventual reserves…underlying reasons and the mechanics for that are quite different….nevertheless, one more interesting avenue for global investors to speculate on 😊
Hey Ashish. I think a currency's internationalization status is decided less by how much it's used in transactions, and more by how much it's used to issue and settle loans. Of course, the first leads to the second, but transactions for long-term assets are where the game is at, and the transition from the first to the second is where China is budging only too slowly. No matter what the underlying mechanics, this condition is important.
The distinction between onshore panda bonds and offshore dim-sum bonds is important when interpreting the issuance boom. A lower yuan yield can attract borrowers without proving that the currency is displacing the dollar in global reserves. For a borrower whose revenues are in another currency, the cost and availability of hedging also matter alongside the headline coupon. How much of the recent issuance reflects natural yuan funding needs versus borrowers swapping the proceeds into another currency?
Thank you for this comment!
So Andy Mukherjee, who we quoted at the start of the piece, takes the exact opposite position. He believes that the yields themselves fundamentally reflect perceptions of investor stability. Now, it's very likely that the dollar will stabilize again - it's the dollar, after all. But this might be a step above mere currency arbitrage (which is what happened in earlier episodes of yuan bond booms).
That distinction between currency use in long-term assets and everyday transactions is helpful; deeper bond markets can develop without immediately changing reserve behavior. What evidence would you watch to tell whether that transition is actually accelerating?
Good piece. The number that stayed with me is the gap itself. China ten year at about 1.6 percent, the US ten year at 5.34 percent in early October. When borrowing in yuan costs a third of borrowing in dollars, the boom needs no grand story about the dollar losing its crown. It is arithmetic. The part I keep thinking about is who pays for the cheap price. Chinese savers earn under 1 percent on a one year deposit while their savings fund the bonds, so the subsidy runs from households to borrowers. That is why I read this as a funding trade, not a reserve currency shift. The dollar is still about 57 percent of global reserves. The boom lasts exactly as long as the rate gap does, and after a hot CPI print that gap is the thing to watch.
Bring the ATF under GST or under uniform VAT percentage across states. Similar to GST cuts of last year, maybe more people flying will offset loss in revenue because of change in taxes...
While India may be cheapest amongst highest 7 flying markets, not sure whether this is PPP adjusted, flying is still expensive for even the average office going Indians, forget the rest..
Maybe more premium trains like VB sleeper across major cities will be people's alternatives to flying..
On the PPP front, you got the argument correctly. Adjusting for affordability, even though the prices looks the least amongst other nations, its still out of reach for many and there's no denying that.
As for alternatives to flying, we too wanted to pursue this angle in our story, but couldn't find convincing enough data points and evidence to include it. So we decided to skip it for now, but will for sure keep a track of it.
Two types of bonds from same underlying currency with the intent to spread the currency globally….interesting…but difficult to understand how can that help in improving the currency domination in global transaction and eventual reserves…underlying reasons and the mechanics for that are quite different….nevertheless, one more interesting avenue for global investors to speculate on 😊
Hey Ashish. I think a currency's internationalization status is decided less by how much it's used in transactions, and more by how much it's used to issue and settle loans. Of course, the first leads to the second, but transactions for long-term assets are where the game is at, and the transition from the first to the second is where China is budging only too slowly. No matter what the underlying mechanics, this condition is important.